Corey and I have waxed poetic numerous times on the used games industry, but recently Jeff Vogel of Spiderweb Software also had some words to chime in with. Regarding the quote of THQ’s Cory Ledesma (which Corey had some opinion on last week himself), Vogel found himself coming on the wrong side of the debate with the Penny Arcade folks who I saw, surprisingly, condemning the sale of used games.
Vogel makes a good argument that I’ve been thinking myself as well, regarding the application of the argument against used games to other used markets, such as the book market. Basically, the idea is that books, like games, are a vehicle for transmitting ideas and art. They are objects that you are allowed by law to sell or give away as you see fit. Being able to circulate these ideas freely, such as with used markets or libraries, is a good idea.
The argument regarding the used games industry really comes down to this, in my opinion. There are members of the game industry that feel that every single person who wants to play a game must buy a legitimate copy of that game from the original publisher/developer because not doing so is “taking money” from that publisher/developer. Which, by extension, means that everyone who enjoys playing a copy of the game that they did not buy is taking money out of the pocket of the publisher/developer…no matter what form they are enjoying it.
This includes coming over to a person’s house to play their game with them. This includes playing a game with your kids. This includes having multiple copies of the game on multiple computers in your house so that you aren’t having to purchase a copy for every single child. This includes LAN parties.
How can anyone engaging in these activities justify it if they hold that philosophy I mentioned above? By some definition, PAX itself is a Used Game-Playing Convention.
This type of thinking feels more to me like overwrought greed rather than justified alarm. No other industry seems to have such hand-wringing when it comes to used items. I mean, I don’t see the book publishing industry making libraries or the used book industry illegal. I don’t see the clothing industry making second-hand stores or hand-me-downs illegal.
Perhaps the Game Industry needs to rethink their fears.