UPDATE: Gendai Games has finally made an official and more comprehensive statement regarding this issue in both the forum thread and their company blog. They assure everyone that, after “extensive research”, they believe that everyone using the GameSalad tool should have no problem continuing to publish their games to the App Store. However, to secure this, they intend to release “updates to the GameSalad tool in the near future to further reinforce that clause 3.3.1 of the iPhone OS 4.0 Agreement will not be an issue for GameSalad or the developers who use it.”
GameSalad is the third major middleware game developer to possibly be affected by Thursday’s iPhone OS 4.0 announcement that included the controversial change to the developer agreement, “Applications that link to Documented APIs through an intermediary translation or compatibility layer or tool are prohibited”.
We’ve already talked with both Unity3D and GarageGames about their thoughts. So, where does GameSalad think they fall in the agreement?
Michael Agustin, CEO of Gendai Games, the developer of the GameSalad tool, told us that he, as other middleware developers, has not had any indication from Apple that anything has changed. Further, he stressed that if changes were necessary, Gendai Games would easily be able to make the alterations necessary.
“Gendai Games have always had a good relationship with Apple, and they have not indicated to us that things will change,” said, Michael Agustin. “GameSalad is architected in such a way that we anticipate no problems adhering to the iPhone PLA.”
However, if one looks on the GameSalad forums, one finds a slightly different story. The forum thread regarding this issue is, as of this story printing, eleven pages long, and shows no signs of slowing down. The posts within the thread contain all manner of speculation as to the fate of GameSalad, Gendai Games, and the games that these developers have created using the tool.
Two posts have been made by a representative of the company on the forum thread, and neither are quite so positive or reassuring. The second one, posted two days ago, says in part:
Another day, another few logs on the fire. Hurray for rivalries! Dunno if it’s much consolation, but our original 3 statements stand, with a slight modification.
1) We’re still looking into it.
2) We still don’t think it will be a problem.
3) We’re clever. And clever people always have a plan.
Well… it’s not technically true. Clever people don’t ALWAYS have a plan. But if they don’t, they can come up with them very quickly. Keep the faith!
We were surprised to see a more conservative and somewhat uneasy post by the company in the forums then what had been made to us. With something this controversial and frightening for the developers using the tool, we would have thought that a more comprehensive statement would have been made by now to the company blog or this forum thread. Regardless, we will keep you up to date regarding this controversial and fascinating topic.